THE FOLLOWING ARE MEMBERS OF THE CFA HALL OF FAME:
| Inductee | Team | Year |
| A. Joseph Cribari | St. Catherine's Laboure | 2006 |
| Jack Mitchell | Good Shepherd | 2007 |
| Rory Morrison | Boiling Springs | 2007 |
| Robert Keith | Cedar Cliff | 2007 |
| Jake Wilson | Holy Name | 2008 |
| Ron Kable | Northern York | 2008 |
| Gabe Buglio | Holy Name | 2009 |
| Ron Matinchek | Seven Sorrows | 2009 |
| Robert Straining | Harrisburg Broncos | 2009 |
| Dick Huber | Seven Sorrows | 2009 |
| Ronnie Christ | St. Margaret Mary | 2009 |
| Walt Clews | St. Margaret Mary | 2009 |
| A.J. Salusti | Holy Name | 2010 |
| Chuck Bissell | Good Shepherd | 2010 |
| John Reiprich | New Cumberland | 2010 |
| Roger Drake | New Cumberland | 2010 |
| Ron Lewis | PIAA Official | 2010 |
| Sam Rhoads | Boiling Springs | 2010 |
| Al Rozzi | Holy Name | 2011 |
| Danny Hoover | Good Shepherd | 2011 |
| Keith Potteiger | New Cumberland | 2011 |
| Tony Buglio | Holy Name | 2011 |
| Brad Humer | Good Shepherd | 2011 |
| David Bickel | Halifax | 2011 |
| Derek Lewis | Steelton | 2012 |
| Ted Matter | East Pennsboro | 2012 |
| Leon Eckman | Red Land | 2012 |
| Mike Ritter | Good Shepherd | 2012 |
| Steve Bodley | Juniata | 2012 |
| Keith Newkam | New Cumberland | 2012 |
| Jeff Enders | Halifax | 2012 |
| Bob Stone III | Seven Sorrows | 2013 |
| Doug Smith | Good Shepherd | 2013 |
| Tim Cramer | Cumberland Valley | 2013 |
| Eric Morrow | Carlisle | 2013 |
| Charles A. Chisholm, Jr. | Harrisburg Packers | 2013 |
| James R. Colston, Jr. | Harrisburg Packers | 2013 |
| Soloman McGraw | Swatara | 2014 |
| Tim McMullen | Good Shepherd | 2014 |
| Alan Perez | Middletown | 2014 |
| James Matolyak | Cumberland Valley | 2014 |
| Rich Sadlock | Holy Name | 2015 |
| Marv Gregg | Swatara | 2015 |
Sam Glesner
Steve Baltimore
Byron Hudson
John Sabol
Todd Fries
Julius Allen | Boiling Springs
Harrisburg Broncos
Good Shepherd
Cumberland Valley
East Pennsboro
Swatara
| 2015
2016
2016
2016
2017
2017
|
| Nicole Adams | Big Spring | 2018 |
| Rhett Heiple | Cedar Cliff | 2018 |
| Joe Cobb | Harrisburg | 2018 |
| Sonny Pacifico | Red Land/Cumberland Valley | 2019 |
| | |