THE FOLLOWING ARE MEMBERS OF THE CFA HALL OF FAME:
| Inductee | Team | Year |
| A. Joseph Cribari | St. Catherine's Laboure | 2006 |
| Jack Mitchell | Good Shepherd | 2007 |
| Rory Morrison | Boiling Springs | 2007 |
| Robert Keith | Cedar Cliff | 2007 |
| Jake Wilson | Holy Name | 2008 |
| Ron Kable | Northern York | 2008 |
| Gabe Buglio | Holy Name | 2009 |
| Ron Matinchek | Seven Sorrows | 2009 |
| Robert Straining | Harrisburg Broncos | 2009 |
| Dick Huber | Seven Sorrows | 2009 |
| Ronnie Christ | St. Margaret Mary | 2009 |
| Walt Clews | St. Margaret Mary | 2009 |
| A.J. Salusti | Holy Name | 2010 |
| Chuck Bissell | Good Shepherd | 2010 |
| John Reiprich | New Cumberland | 2010 |
| Roger Drake | New Cumberland | 2010 |
| Ron Lewis | PIAA Official | 2010 |
| Sam Rhoads | Boiling Springs | 2010 |
| Al Rozzi | Holy Name | 2011 |
| Danny Hoover | Good Shepherd | 2011 |
| Keith Potteiger | New Cumberland | 2011 |
| Tony Buglio | Holy Name | 2011 |
| Brad Humer | Good Shepherd | 2011 |
| David Bickel | Halifax | 2011 |
| Derek Lewis | Steelton | 2012 |
| Ted Matter | East Pennsboro | 2012 |
| Leon Eckman | Red Land | 2012 |
| Mike Ritter | Good Shepherd | 2012 |
| Steve Bodley | Juniata | 2012 |
| Keith Newkam | New Cumberland | 2012 |
| Jeff Enders | Halifax | 2012 |
| Bob Stone III | Seven Sorrows | 2013 |
| Doug Smith | Good Shepherd | 2013 |
| Tim Cramer | Cumberland Valley | 2013 |
| Eric Morrow | Carlisle | 2013 |
| Charles A. Chisholm, Jr. | Harrisburg Packers | 2013 |
| James R. Colston, Jr. | Harrisburg Packers | 2013 |
| Soloman McGraw | Swatara | 2014 |
| Tim McMullen | Good Shepherd | 2014 |
| Alan Perez | Middletown | 2014 |
| James Matolyak | Cumberland Valley | 2014 |
| Rich Sadlock | Holy Name | 2015 |
| Marv Gregg | Swatara | 2015 |
Sam Glesner
Steve Baltimore
Byron Hudson
John Sabol
Todd Fries
Julius Allen | Boiling Springs
Harrisburg Broncos
Good Shepherd
Cumberland Valley
East Pennsboro
Swatara
| 2015
2016
2016
2016
2017
2017
|
| Nicole Adams | Big Spring | 2018 |
| Rhett Heiple | Cedar Cliff | 2018 |
| Joe Cobb | Harrisburg | 2018 |
| Sonny Pacifico | Red Land/Cumberland Valley | 2019 |
Rocky Magaro
Jeff Heshler
Scott Lamprey
Joe Wilson
Kem Bonner
Arron Wright
Dennis Flipovich
Dan Furman
Charles Fox
Grant Fox
Bruce Walbert
Steve Messick
Mike Souders
Phil Shirk
Steve Hornbaker
Barry Donbaugh
Matt Fries
Brian Bower
Chris Allen | East Pennsboro
Central Dauphin
PIAA Official
Carlisle
Harrisburg
Greenwood-Newport
Cumberland Valley
Gettysburg
Red Land
Susquehanna Township/Harrisburg/Red Land
Cumberland Valley
Lower Dauphin
Lower Dauphin
Northern Lebanon
East Pennsboro
East Pennsboro
PIAA Official
Greenwood-Newport
Tri-Community | 2021
2021
2021
2021
2022
2022
2022
2022
2022
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023
2023 |
| Dave Pinz | Susquenita | 2024 |
| Billy Owens | Carlisle | 2024 |
| David Kline | Northern Lebanon | 2024 |
| Juan Bratcher | Tri-Community | 2024 |
| Brian Peterson | Steelton | 2024 |
| Peter Tarpline | Cumberland Valley | 2024 |
| Ian Worrell | East Pennsboro | 2025 |
| Tay Jones | Chambersburg | 2025 |
| Tom Peifer Sr | Red Land | 2025 |
| Eric Thorton | Good Shepherd/Shamrocks | 2025 |
| Aaron Slade | Tri Community | 2025 |